Completed in 2023, Marylebone’s first new city block in 50 years promised to be an exciting development.

The £120 million development replaced the Moxon Street Car Park, one of central London’s last major undeveloped spaces, with 79 high end and affordable apartments ranging up to £23 million.

A 3,500 sq ft space set aside for community use, originally as a market hall, was one of the project’s hallmarks, however three years later the huge space in the beige city block remains dormant. So where did things go wrong?

Marylebone Hall was set to be a new community hub, but the space earmarked for the scheme remains empty three years later (Picture: WT)

The new city block

Rewind back to 2016 and developers Concord were given the green-light to transform a car park in the heart of Marylebone, which also acted as the site of the weekly farmers’ market, into a major mixed-use development – a rare clean slate project in central London.

Victorian homes on the site had been demolished under slum clearance rules during the 1960s with a view to building a primary school that never materialised.

Prior to 2011, an agreement prevented Westminster City Council from selling off the land without the permission of the Secretary of State for Housing.

In exchange for the rights to the unique opportunity, Concord, the firm behind another major development on Great Portland Street, was required to provide space in the development for a community hall to house the Sunday market, which had since temporarily relocated to Aybrook Street.

However London Farmers Markets objected to using the newly designed indoor space, indicating a preference for keeping stalls in the open-air.

Since the market’s temporary planning consent and license to remain on the surrounding streets was extended, the large hall it would have taken has stood idle.

Elsewhere, several of the ground floor retail units remain empty. While a cafe and bakery have filled some spaces, others remain blank after being advertised for several years as opportunities within a stone’s throw of Marylebone High Street.

Some new arrivals appeared to be in the offing, including Dutch outfitters SuitSupply at the Moxon Street end, however few signs of work are apparent several months after signs promoting the upcoming store were pasted on the windows this summer.

An opportunity

Marylebone Hall also remains largely dormant. In September 2025, Marylebone Association (MA) was chosen by Westminster City Council as its preferred operator for the hall, which it would be managed through a Community Interest Company (CIC).

When the Marylebone Square project began to take shape, hopes were raised part of the space could become a permanent library, to replace the temporary facility on New Cavendish Street.

But talks were also simultaneously underway with a local school to take over part of the development’s basement as a gym and other educational space. The proposals were opposed by community groups who wanted a space with more natural light.

A major issue is the building’s leasing arrangements, which restrict the council from subletting parts of the development to third parties.

The project also needs a significant amount of funding to repurpose the large room, which was designed as an unheated lobby for market stalls. Funding was hoped to be secured from the Neighbourhood Community Infrastructure Levy (NCIL), however the funds were since redirected into other schemes including the redevelopment of the Seymour Leisure Centre.

‘Westminster [Council]’s role in this is not a happy one really. There’s a been a lot of messing around’, a source at MA said.

While negotiations for the community hall have struggled, WT understands the space was briefly let out to an orchestra and an exhibition for several days.

The ownership of Marylebone Square is itself a complex question. The whole site is leased for 999 years to a firm called Moxon Street Residential (Luxembourg) Ltd, a firm with links to Hong Kong architect Yiu Bong Un.

The deal gave the local authority a long under-lease covering areas of the ground floor, including the proposed community hall, while allowing the commercial space to be leased back.

But to complicate matters further, the lease contained a covenant prohibiting activities ‘causing nuisance, inconvenience or disturbance’ – a potential sticking point for the planned use of the community hall.

This is a case of ‘what are you waiting for’

Although many of the building’s ground floor retail units are now let, some large spaces remain empty (Picture: WT)

For others, the long-term vacancy of the space is giving rise to other concerns relating to security.

Christopher Murray, the managing director of developer Concord London, expressed concerns about the space remaining empty for years, including the possibility of rough sleeping and it becoming a magnet for crime.

He told WT: ‘Obviously I don’t want 3,500 sq ft of empty space in a building I built with residents in it. Nobody in the neighbourhood with a brain wants that size high profile space empty on the street. It’s not safe.’

‘This is a classic case of ‘What are you waiting for?”, he said, adding that there was a real risk the hall would be broken into.

He said he collected 1,500 signatures in support of the deal with St Vincent’s school, which would have provided lower ground space with natural light for several student facilities, including a computer room and gym, but this was ‘killed’ by the Marylebone Association.

Mr Murray insisted that the current situation was the result of ‘politics over performance’ and ‘bureaucratic crap’.

A source from MA however, explained that the lower ground space was a very different proposition, and would have been unworkable given that the school would have had control over the hall rather than the wider community.

Even though the two spaces were of equal size, they were not ‘comparable in value’, given the ground floor unit is in an ‘A1 position’, the source added.

‘For them unilaterally to change that without securing a formal revision of the original S106 agreement, is totally wrong’, they added.

With retail space in Marylebone fetching an average of £69 per square foot, the space, if let out commercially, could bring in upwards of £240,000 a year. Mr Murray said he had a majority of the retail units in the building let out.

Mr Murray said: ‘Obviously you can tell I’m a little frustrated by it because it’s such a waste. No-one’s thinking of the community if that’s empty.’

A spokesperson for Westminster City Council said: ‘The Marylebone Hall Project has the potential to be a valuable community asset. Conversations between residents, the council and the building owners are ongoing as we work to find solutions to practical issues over managing the space, funding the capital costs and ongoing services.’

Leave a Reply